star wars episode 3 – revenge of the sith

the circle is now complete

review by mark newbold

 

It’s been an eventful twenty-eight years here on earth since George Lucas unleashed Star Wars on the world on a sunny day in May of 1977.  Three years later John Lennon was shot, three after that Lucas finished his trilogy of original films.  Three years on again and Challenger was destroyed during her launch, three more still and the Berlin Wall fell.  In 1991 the Gulf War was fought and in 1997, the same year Star Wars returned to the big screen with the Special Editions, Tony Blair entered 10 Downing Street, thereby proving that all bad things come to those who wait – which was exactly how many felt about The Phantom Menace when it arrived May 19th 1999.

Here we had an enigma.  A film so fervently anticipated that it could never live up to the hype.  Episode 1, aimed at those same seven year olds the original was designed for, was much maligned for just that reason, and Lucas, quite reasonably, defended his decisions saying that Jar Jar Binks, the most loathed character in Star Wars history, was a huge hit with the under tens.  We met new characters and were reintroduced to some old friends (technically, we had been watching young Ani since the first few shots of Star Wars). And yet, despite a stellar box office of almost a billion dollars worldwide, Menace became the most criticised of the four films.

And so three years on, under close scrutiny, came Attack of the Clones.  Clearly a different film – faster, quicker, more intense – this brought us the teenage Anakin Skywalker, an annoying, whiny and bratty teen who was instantly unlikeable.  In retrospect the backlash was inevitable, bringing claims of wooden scripts and even worse acting.  But Lucas had always said these films were made in the style of the great 30’s adventure serials, whereas the original trilogy had an edgy, 70’s feel to them.  Staying true as ever to the vision he forged ahead.

And thank the Force that he did.

Revenge of the Sith is not only a technical and design triumph, it’s a marvel of storytelling too.  Weaving the gap between the two trilogies (no mean feat, and sure to be helped by the 5 year series that starts in 2007) this is the one we have all been waiting to see.  If a fan had been sat down on May 18th 1999 and asked what they wanted to see from the Prequels, odds are they would have said :-

 

  1. Clone Wars – CHECK
  2. Ben versus Anakin – CHECK
  3. Jedi Purge – CHECK
  4. Luke and Leia born – CHECK

 

Tick away, it’s all here.  If Phantom was the bread roll and Clones the appetiser, Revenge is the main course.  And what a banquet it is for Star Wars fans.

Kicking off with the end of the Clone Wars, the Battle of Coruscant rages above the city planet, and following the opening scrawl into this maelstrom fly Obi Wan and Anakin on a mission to rescue the captured Chancellor Palpatine (nabbed by General Grievous at the end of the Clone Wars second season).  It’s clear from the get-go that the two men’s relationship has matured into that of brothers, and their teamwork soon means that Palpatine is free, although not without its fair share of mishaps. 

As the story progresses it becomes clear that Anakin is unsatisfied with his lot, and he has good cause.  He is constantly shut out by the council, held back by Kenobi and has to hide his love for his wife.  On top of this he had the Chancellor inflating his ego and planting seeds out doubt that blossom at the end of the film.  As Revenge moves forward we feel his frustrations, see the council’s doubts about both him and the Chancellor until, in one of the most stunning scenes in Star Wars history Anakin makes his choice and joins the dark side and Palpatine after the execution of Mace Windu.  From there on in it’s a downward spiral for Anakin and Padme, as she cannot believe her husband capable of the terrible things he is accused of, and Anakin always a tear away from breaking down at his own actions.  Palpatines insistent words and the fear of losing Padme spur Anakin on, until fate and the precise blade of Obi-Wan Kenobi conspire to trap him in the guise and armour of Darth Vader.  From slavery as a child, to servitude in the service of the Jedi and finally, on the cusp of snatching the galaxy from Palpatine, Anakin suffers eternal torment as a wife murderer and slave of the Emperor. 

Revenge of the Sith, as well as being grade `A’ eye candy, is a moving tragedy.   Those final moments on the platform between Padme, Anakin and Ben on Mustafar is so painful to watch, after following their progress in The Phantom Menace, through their teamwork days in Attack of the Clones, to this – you want to scream at them to talk it out, pull back from the precipice.  But you already know their fate.  Anakin will become the fearsome Darth Vader, a man ironically cut down by Kenobi to be no more powerful than any of Sidious’ other apprentices.  Obi-Wan will assume the life of a hermit, training himself in the ways of the Force and watching over young Luke Skywalker.  Padme will give birth to twins and die of a broken heart.

As Lucas always said, none of the other films would truly make sense until this final piece was slotted into place, and he was right.  The previous episodes are now cast in a new light, as are the events of the original trilogy.  Vader is now a trapped, broken man.  A man who believed he murdered his pregnant wife with the powers he gained in order to save her.  Ben is also broken, crushed by what he was forced to do and weakened by the burden.  Yoda is no longer the invincible force he once seemed to be, Palpatine is even more diabolical.  And of all the Jedi, Qui-Gon is revealed to possibly be the wisest and most powerful of all, teaching both Kenobi and Yoda a better way – something Anakin would have done well to learn.

As an end to a trilogy this far surpasses Return of the Jedi.  As the end of the Star Wars saga it’s hard to imagine a better finale.  If nothing else, the Prequel trilogy has thrown a million new questions out into fandom, and thank heavens for that. 

Revenge of the Sith sits comfortably alongside A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back as the very cream of the saga and, perhaps unlike its two Prequel predecessors, genuinely hits the mark in excitement, drama and quality delivery that so shone through the first two Original Trilogy entries. 

Lucas may have taken three films to rediscover it, but finally the Force is back.